One That Got Away NYC is a women owned business, founded by sisters with a deep love for treasure hunting and sustainability. We carry a distinctively curated vintage collection of women’s clothing, jewelry, and charming children’s pieces. We strive to fill your closet with vintage finds that are unique, timeless, and tell a story. When you shop with us, you’re not just finding something to wear, you’re becoming part of history.

We’re here for any questions and look forward to having you check out our store!